• Home

  • FIND A RETAILER

  • MENU

  • ABOUT

  • CONTACT

  • More

    Use tab to navigate through the menu items.

    Pantry 1, in Apple Creek

    668 W. Main St., Apple Creek, Ohio 44606

    Tel.330-698-4182

    Hours: 6am to 6pm Tues-Fri, 7am to 5pm Sat. Closed Sunday and Monday

    Call Us at Apple Creek

    Pantry 2, in Wooster

    319 E. North St, Wooster, OH 44691

    Tel.330-263-1990

    Drive Thru Hours: Tues-Fri 6am to 2pm, Sat 7am to 2pm

    Store Hours: Tues-Fri 7am to 2pm, Sat 7am to 1:30pm

    Closed Sunday and Monday

    Call us at Wooster
    We're not accepting online orders yet. Please contact us to complete the order.
    Pickup, ASAP (in 15 minutes)
    • Pies
    • Pastries and Breads
    Our MenuPiesPastries and Breads

    Our Menu

    Original Recipes, Timeless Flavors

    Pies

    So many favorites... Try them all!

    Traditional Cream Pies include Lemon Meringue, Coconut, Banana, Peanut Butter, Chocolate, and Chocolate Peanut Butter.
    $9.259.25 USD
    A flavorful twist! These cream pies have a vanilla pudding base topped with a raspberry or blueberry glaze and finished with whipped topping. Want something richer? Try a whipped cheesecake on a graham crust topped with fruit glaze.
    $11.2511.25 USD
    A Seasonal Favorite! Available from late March to late August.
    Special
    $11.2511.25 USD Sold Out
    Sold Out
    Includes Cherry, Cherry Crumb, Blueberry, Blackberry, Red Raspberry, Elderberry, and Triple Berry Pies Black Raspberry Pies are currently unavailable.
    $10.0010.00 USD
    Includes Apple, Dutch Apple, Peach, Rhubarb, Rhubarb Crumb, Pumpkin, and Custard Pies
    $9.259.25 USD
    Our famous Pumpkin Pies
    $9.259.25 USD
    Pecan Pies
    $11.2511.25 USD

    Pastries and Breads

    Breads, Cakes, Cookies... CINNAMON ROLLS!

    White and Donut Bread (made from our raised donut dough, it's light and slightly sweet!)
    $2.202.20 USD
    $3.253.25 USD
    Our famous Cinnamon Rolls with Maple Frosting
    $5.255.25 USD
    Our delicious Cinnamon Rolls topped with Pecans
    $5.955.95 USD
    Chocolate Chip, Butterscotch Oatmeal, Peanut Butter, Monster, Oatmeal Raisin, Frosted Sugar(Christmas Cookies seasonally), and Molasses Cookies. You might say we like making cookies!
    $5.005.00 USD
    Our original recipe pumpkin sheet cake frosted with our cream cheese frosting and cut into bars. One bite and you'll be hooked!
    $5.255.25 USD
    Our pumpkin bars topped with walnuts
    $5.955.95 USD
    The most substantial angel food cake you've ever eaten! Serves 12 generous pieces. Delicious with fresh fruit and/or whipped topping. Available as the traditional white angel food cake and also in 6 flavors; Lemon, Chocolate, and Strawberry.
    $7.007.00 USD
    Decadent Chocolate Brownies with chocolate chips baked into the cake!
    $5.255.25 USD
    Subscribe for hot updates

    Created with Wix.com